What is the difference between TMC22226 and TMC2225? Which one is the best for you?

TMC2225 vs. TMC2226: The Silent Stepper Driver Showdown (2023 Edition)

Sleek. Silent. Precise. These attributes define Trinamic’s revolutionary StealthChop2 technology, powering both the TMC2225 and TMC2226 stepper motor drivers. At first glance, these two drivers appear nearly identical – both champions of quiet operation and smooth motion. But beneath the surface, critical distinctions define their ideal applications. Let’s dissect these engineering marvels and reveal which driver emerges as your project’s perfect ally.

Core Architectural Kinship:

• StealthChop2: Shared across both drivers, this patented technology delivers near-silent operation at low-to-medium speeds, eliminating the classic stepper motor "whine."
• SpreadCycle™: Provides robust torque control at high speeds for both ICs, ensuring steps aren’t missed under demanding loads.
• StallGuard4™: Enables high-resolution sensorless stall detection and homing, eliminating the need for mechanical endstops.
• CoolStep™: Dynamically adjusts motor current based on real-time load (back-EMF), significantly reducing energy consumption and heat generation.
• High-Resolution Microstepping: Both support up to 1/256 microstepping for exceptionally smooth motion profiles.
• UART Interface: Programmable settings (current, microstepping, threshold levels) via serial communication.

Divergence: Where TMC2225 and TMC2226 Part Ways

Unpacking the Technical Nuances:

1. The Power Factor: The TMC2225-QFN28 is unequivocally the powerhouse. Its higher current rating (2.5A) and wider voltage range (36V) empower it to drive larger NEMA 17 or even small NEMA 23 motors demanding substantial torque. The exceptionally low RDS(ON) (120mΩ) enhances efficiency significantly. The TMC2226 (both packages) caps at 2.0A RMS/29V, targeting the broad NEMA 17 market segment.
2. The Size Factor: TMC2226-QFN24 (4x4mm) is the indisputable champion of miniaturization. If your PCB real estate is strictly limited, this tiny footprint unlocks possibilities the larger QFN28 TMC2225 cannot. Both ICs offer an MSOP16 package option.
3. The MSOP16 Package Battle: This is a critical comparison. The TMC2226-MSOP16 delivers superior performance over its TMC2225-MSOP16 predecessor:
   • Current: 2.0A RMS vs. 1.2A RMS – 67% more current capability!
   • RDS(ON): 300mΩ vs. 500mΩ – 44% lower resistance!
   • This dramatic improvement makes the TMC2226-MSOP16 a viable, high-performance SMD option where the older TMC2225-LA was constrained. The TMC2225-QFN28 remains superior for raw power.
4. Thermal Management (Implications): Lower RDS(ON) directly translates to reduced heat generation for the same output current. The TMC2225-QFN28 generates the least heat under high load. The TMC2226-QFN24/LA will typically run warmer at 2A than a TMC2225-QFN28 at 2A. Adequate heatsinking (exposed thermal pad) is crucial, especially for the MSOP16 packages at full rated current.

The Verdict: Which Driver is Your Ideal Match?

Selecting between TMC2225 and TMC2226 hinges on the core demands of your application:

• You NEED the TMC2225-QFN28 if:

  • Driving motors requiring > 2.0A RMS.
  • Operating within a bus voltage above 29V (up to 36V).
  • Pushing thermal performance to the limit demands the absolute lowest RDS(ON) (120mΩ).
  • Application: High-power 3D printer extruders, CNC spindles, large automation axes, robust laboratory equipment.

• The TMC2226-QFN24 Shines When:

  • Ultra-compact design is non-negotiable. The 4x4mm footprint provides unparalleled integration.
  • Motor requirements fall comfortably < 2.0A RMS.
  • The power supply voltage is ≤ 29V.
  • Application: Dense PCB layouts (IoT devices, robotics joints, miniaturized instruments, portable diagnostic gear).
• The TMC2226-MSOP16 (TMC2226-LA) is Perfect for:
  • Applications where MSOP16 SMD packaging is standard or preferred over QFN.
  • Needing a significant (2.0A RMS) current in an MSOP16 package – impossible with the older TMC2225-LA.
  • Excellent balance of performance and solderability compared to QFN.
  • Application: Upgrading existing MSOP16 designs, moderate-power modules, space-critical designs needing well-established SMD packaging.

Beyond RAW Specs: The Hidden Synergy

Both drivers exemplify Trinamic’s core philosophy: Intelligent Motion Control. Features like StallGuard4 and CoolStep transform simple stepper pulses into smart motion systems. Integrating either driver (especially via UART) allows your controller to dynamically optimize performance – detect stalls silently, reduce idle current waste, and achieve fluid, precise movement previously reserved for complex servo systems.

Conclusion: Precision Engineering, Purpose-Driven Choices

The TMC2225 and TMC2226 are not competitors in a zero-sum game, but rather complementary solutions within Trinamic’s engineering hierarchy. The TMC2225-QFN28 stands as the capacious powerhouse, dominating scenarios demanding brute force and wide voltage. The TMC2226-QFN24 represents the pinnacle of miniaturization, enabling sophisticated motion control where millimeters matter. The TMC2226-MSOP16 redefines the potential of the classic SMD package, offering compelling performance in a familiar footprint.

Your Choice?

• Demand Power & Voltage Headroom? TMC2225-QFN28.
• Conquering Micro-Designs? TMC2226-QFN24.
• Revolutionizing MSOP16 Legacy? TMC2226-LA.

Choose the driver that harmonizes with your project’s kinetic ambition – and unlock motion with uncompromising silence and intelligence.